A small, intimate, and somewhat autobiographical drama by South African playwright Athol Fugard, Master Harold…and the Boys can land like a gut punch, and thematically and linguistically, it absolutely does.
The new production at the Geffen Playhouse in West Los Angeles is strikingly designed and led by an acting legend, but it doesn’t always hit with the full emotional weight it’s capable of, occasionally feeling a bit rushed in places that might have benefited from more space to breathe.
The award-winning play takes place in a tea room in 1950s South Africa. There, two Black men, the elder Sam (John Kani) and the younger Willie (Nyasha Hatendi), keep the place running on a rainy day with no customers in sight. The two share an easy camaraderie, with Willie often turning to Sam for advice on love and ballroom dancing.
See Also: Theater Review: Disco, Dictatorship, and Dissonance: “Here Lies Love” Lands in L.A.
That warmth extends to Hally (Ben Beatty), a young white man who enters to work on his school assignments. Sam and Willie are like family to him, having helped raise him from childhood. Hally is bright, a bit of a know-it-all, and enjoys challenging Sam intellectually, but Sam meets him at every turn with patience and insight. What begins as a friendly back and forth gradually shifts after Hally receives a phone call about his hospitalized, alcoholic father. In that moment, something changes. Hally begins to assert a different kind of authority, treating Sam and Willie as less than, and permanently altering the dynamic between them.
Though written decades ago, the play remains deeply relevant. It explores how racism is learned, absorbed, and ultimately expressed, often in moments of vulnerability or anger. Hally does not fully recognize this part of himself until it surfaces, and despite Sam’s steady compassion and wisdom, the damage is done.
It is a tragic unraveling that shows how quickly kindness can give way to cruelty, how power is internalized, and how even small moments can reinforce larger systems of injustice.
Beatty’s performance captures the character as written, intelligent, restless, and increasingly volatile, but at times moves through key emotional beats a bit quickly. Moments like the phone calls with his parents feel like they could use just a little more space, allowing the shifts in Hally’s behavior to land with even greater impact. Still, he clearly understands the role and navigates its complexities thoughtfully.
John Kani, as Sam, is extraordinary. He brings a quiet authority and emotional depth that anchors the entire production. Given his long history with Fugard, and their shared anti-apartheid activism, there is a lived-in authenticity to his performance that is impossible to ignore. He grounds the play with warmth, dignity, and a presence that commands attention.
Hatendi’s Willie is engaging and sincere, though the role itself is more limited, often requiring him to observe rather than drive the action. He makes the most of those moments and adds a welcome layer of humanity to the piece.
The production is competently directed by Emily Mann and Tarell Alvin McCraney, making effective use of the single set without letting it feel static. The constant rain and subtle shifts in light add texture and atmosphere, quietly reinforcing the play’s emotional landscape.
Master Harold… and the Boys remains an important and powerful work, and Kani alone is reason enough to see this production. It may not fully land at every turn, but its message and the conversation it sparks still resonate in a way that feels necessary to witness.
Master Harold… and the Boys runs through May 10th at the Geffen Playhouse Gil Gates Theater.
For more information and tickets, visit Geffenplayhouse.org.
