After seeing the recent Broadway revival starring Ali Louis Bourzgui (currently playing David in “The Lost Boys”), I was surprised by how much emotional impact and narrative clarity seem to have been lost in the current, truncated touring production of The Who’s Tommy.
Visually, the show looks and feels remarkably similar to what I saw on Broadway, with its dazzling projections, inventive staging, and thrilling choreography. Yet by cutting out an estimated 15 minutes, something has been lost in translation.
On Broadway, the journey Tommy (Collin Matthew Flanagan) goes on – from a traumatized child to a pinball sensation and eventual reluctant messiah – was remarkably clear. Here, the production moves at such a breakneck pace that important narrative developments barely register.
See Also: Theater Review: ‘Mexodus’ Turns Forgotten History Into Unforgettable Theater
While Tommy’s traumatic childhood remains central, certain moments feel strangely muted. His sexual abuse at the hands of Uncle Ernie (Peyton Cassidy), for example, is presented so subtly that audiences unfamiliar with the material might miss its significance entirely. And while the relationship between Tommy and his parents (Mia Bergstrom and Zach Fogel) still carries some emotional weight, it doesn’t resonate nearly as strongly as it did on Broadway.
The problems become even more apparent as Tommy emerges from his isolation and becomes a celebrity. His transformation into a quasi-religious figure, complete with devoted followers who eventually turn against him, feels rushed and underdeveloped. The progression from admiration to worship to outright rejection is clunky, making the sequence hard to follow.
I understood these plot points perfectly when I saw the Broadway production, yet this time I struggled to connect the dots. And I wasn’t alone. My companion experienced much of the same confusion.
Interestingly, a comparison of the Broadway and touring programs suggests that the scenes themselves remain largely intact. It’s difficult to tell whether musical passages have been shortened, transitions accelerated, or certain moments staged differently. But whatever the reason, the storytelling suffers.
That’s particularly unfortunate because The Who’s Tommy is much more than a collection of iconic rock songs. Beneath the spectacle is a deeply emotional story about childhood trauma, exploitation, isolation, and the desperate search for connection. Tommy escapes one form of exploitation only to find himself subjected to another, this time at the hands of those who worship him.
When that emotional journey isn’t clearly communicated, the production risks becoming a series of spectacular musical numbers rather than the powerful, cohesive story it’s capable of being.
Another distraction is having a female (Mari Grossmann) play young Tommy. It was so visually obvious that every moment the character was on stage (which is a lot) it was a distraction.
There is still plenty to admire in this touring production. All the performers are strong, including Kris Lyons as the Acid Queen (made famous by Tina Turner in the film version). Flanagan has the vocal chops, but lacks the charisma needed to make the character land. (Although he did remind one of the original band member and star of the film version, Roger Daltry, throughout.) The set design and energetic staging are electric, and Lorin Latarro’s choreography definitely has its moments and helps distract from the uneven storytelling.
Unfortunately, it’s disappointing to see how much emotional resonance and story comprehension seem to have been lost between the Broadway revival and the National Tour. In NYC, I knew nothing about Tommy’s story and fell in love with the production. Here, I was befuddled, as were others in the audience, many of whom checked out about halfway through.
For fans of The Who, this will certainly deliver. Casual theatergoers might not find this the “Amazing Journey” they hoped for.



