At a key point in Captain America: Brave New World, Harrison Ford’s President Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross growls out to Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson, “You may be Captain America, but you’re not Steve Rogers.” It’s the sort of moment that would ideally sum up the challenge of this Phase 5 Marvel Cinematic Universe film, which is in a prime position to tackle the presence of this specific actor now occupying the role of an iconic hero. Disney+’s 2021 series, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, already botched its chance at doing a good job with this (and for the record, it is not at all required viewing), but ideally, the current titan of movie franchises could find a way in. Alas, that’s not really the case. Instead, Brave New World settles for being a conventional action thriller, where complications only arise in the number of angles being covered, as opposed to anything worth digging deeper into. With all of that in mind, it provides lightweight fun for those seeking blockbuster entertainment but still makes me pine for where Cap was at a decade prior.
Back in 2014, when Captain America: The Winter Soldier delivered a stunningly great superhero movie at the end of the Spring movie season, it was the first half of a year that proved how bulletproof the Marvel Studios brand had become (the August 2014 release of a film featuring the obscure characters known as the Guardians of the Galaxy would truly solidify the brand). Rather than go over that history, however, the real contrast I want to highlight is just how refreshing that movie felt at the time. Sure, it’s not particularly innovative in the plotting, but it was an A-level example of how these MCU films could approximate a certain kind of subgenre (spy thriller) and imbue it with superhero theatrics and special effects.
See Also: ‘Kraven The Hunter’ Review: Sony’s Most Dangerous Game Ends
Brave New World is coming at a point when we’ve already seen Captain America accomplish incredible feats that range from taking down compromised government institutions to stopping an alien invasion (twice). More importantly, however, his adventures were generally well-assembled. I point to The Winter Solider specifically because of how grounded in a level of reality it aimed to be. This 2025 entry, with Sam Wilson sporting both wings and Cap’s shield, frankly, doesn’t look as good.
For every clever deployment of Sam’s abilities in a wingsuit or the reminder of a giant Celestial Body in the middle of the Indian Ocean (a leftover from Eternals), simple things such as characters standing out in broad daylight look like last-minute replacements for other scenes. Ample use of news broadcast voiceover serves as the glue in a two-hour (with credits) movie that suggests things have been considerably paired down. So, the question becomes – why have things become so difficult for stories that could offer intrigue yet remain exciting and straightforward in presentation.
It’s a frustration that comes from me inching close to what I wish this movie was about, but that’s also not fair to what’s been presented, regardless of how I feel about it. Would I be so critical of Brave New World’s visual hiccups if I also contended with a story about a Black Captain America’s role in an America now governed by an erratic former U.S. General? This could speak to a more considerable challenge the MCU has placed on itself in the realm of overpromising when it comes to the future of this franchise as a whole, which can undercut the stakes of these individual entries. So then one has to consider just how well something like what Brave New World offers will deliver for someone just looking for an action blockbuster.
While complications arise, the plot has an easy throughline to keep track of. Sam’s friend and mentor, Isaiah Bradley (Carl Lumbly, the film’s MVP), one of the original super soldiers, has been set up for attempting to assassinate the President. Knowing something sinister is behind this, Sam works against President Ross’ wishes to discover the truth, enlisting the help of the new Falcon, Joaquin Torres (a winning Danny Ramirez). Some smaller and bigger threats reveal themselves, whether it’s Giancarlo Esposito’s Sidewinder or Tim Blake Nelson’s Samuel Sterns. Still, Sam only really has his work cut out for him when dealing with Thunderbolt Ross’ true angry side.
Early on, director Julius Onah (Luce) shows some promise, not unlike Ryan Coogler as far as adding certain cultural elements to help this film stand out. However, that ends pretty quickly once we get past character introductions and have the story play out. It is not entirely unexpected, but one does hope some sense of style is maintained, and yes, as locked into a certain level of formatting as it is, there is the sense that Onah wants to deliver a crackerjack spy thriller on his own terms, despite whatever compromises needed to be made.
The action on display is exciting in the moment. With wings and a shield, there are plenty of fun ways to watch Sam handle himself in battle, though the film doesn’t forget to show how vulnerable he can be. Does this same energy extend to other types of confrontations? It’s a mixed bag. Being a film based on comic books, let alone the 35th cinematic entry in an ongoing series, familiar beats are at play that keep things from ever really delivering much in the way of surprise. More frustrating is seeing the film repeat specific issues again and again, as if this film is worried that the entire audience didn’t catch certain beats the first time.
Performance-wise, mostly everyone is up to the ask. Mackie makes for a good Captain America who may not be too concerned with how deserving he is of the shield but certainly lets the weight of his responsibility play on his face while still having fun with the role. Among others not already mentioned, Shira Haas pops up as the President’s head of security, and the slight Israeli actress does plenty to hold her own in this cast. Villain-wise, Nelson isn’t about to enter a “Bests” list, but Esposito is at least having fun in a role he can play in his sleep.
This brings us to the great Harrison Ford, who actively sought to join the MCU and is here replacing the late William Hurt. I wish I had better things to say here. Still, aside from the novelty of having one of the greatest movie stars of all time in a Captain America movie, Ford really isn’t shining at his brightest here. As a character required to have questionable motives, his duress seems far more like plot manipulation than an actor having fun delving into his dark side that led to far more successful performances in the past.
Now, there is joy in knowing Captain America: Brave New World has a key confrontation it is building toward. Helping with this is the film’s solid pacing, which keeps everyone moving. Whether or not one feels the story falls flat, we shift around in location often enough to at least appreciate the desire to carry things forward and have characters discover things on the move. Yes, I may have wished that discussions about matters that will affect the future of the MCU could be traded in for more concerns focusing on the old and new approaches to super soldiers and vigilantes of all races, colors, and creeds in America. However, I also can’t say the standard expectations for Marvel movies at this point aren’t met. This is not The First Avenger, but I don’t at all mind watching Sam hang onto the shield.












