While Dylan O’Brien has been in plenty of films since his breakout in MTV’s Teen Wolf and has always been reliably terrific, his performance in James Sweeney’s Twinless should finally put him on the map as one of the up-and-coming greats.
Sweeney writes, directs, and co-stars in this haunting dramedy about Roman (O’Brien), a young man reeling from the loss of his twin brother Rocky in a car accident. On the advice of his grieving mother, Lisa (Lauren Graham), Roman joins a support group for twins who have lost their other half. There, he meets Dennis (Sweeney), who reaches out to him after the meeting. The two form a fast friendship, especially once Roman discovers Dennis is gay, a connection that reminds him of his late brother Rocky. But as the pair navigate the overwhelming grief of being cut in half, a deeper, more complicated secret begins to surface.
See Also: ‘Eden’ Review: Ron Howard’s Fascinating True-Life Tale of Paradise Lost
Twinless isn’t a film full of shocking twists and turns, but it’s better not to reveal more than that. What can be said is that Sweeney’s script is a perceptive and profound exploration of twinhood, grief, guilt, and regret. His direction is carefully crafted and sometimes quietly clever, never flashy, yet always providing us with subtle insights into the story and its characters. His portrayal of Dennis is particularly tricky: his likability is questionable as his attachment to Roman deepens, yet he remains compelling throughout. More than once, I found myself yelling at the screen, hoping Dennis would make better choices.
The supporting cast adds texture. Graham, as always, is luminous; she doesn’t have many scenes, but she makes them count. Aisling Franciosi plays a co-worker of Dennis who becomes romantically involved with Roman, creating natural friction between the two peers. Franciosi brings a subtle resilience to the role, with her perpetually upbeat nature masking the depth she quietly carries.
But the heart of Twinless belongs to O’Brien. As Roman, he delivers a nuanced portrayal of a soft-spoken man haunted by unbearable grief. Roman’s mumbling hesitations, his quiet admissions, and his bursts of anger (which he often regrets) feel authentic and heartbreaking. A hotel room scene in which Dennis role-plays as Rocky so Roman can say the words he never got to say is, quite simply, Oscar-worthy.
On top of that, O’Brien also plays Rocky, his late twin. Rocky is everything Roman is not: confident, free-spirited, magnetic. O’Brien’s turn as Rocky is vibrant, charming, and refreshingly free of caricature. It recalls Robin Williams’ flamboyance in The Birdcage but with a grounded accuracy that makes Rocky unforgettable. Seeing O’Brien switch so seamlessly between the restrained Roman and the effervescent Rocky is a revelation.
Twinless is compelling from start to finish, and what makes it so engrossing is its authenticity. Even when characters frustrate us, they feel real. Grief makes people messy, complicated, and sometimes unlikable. That truth keeps us invested.
Whether or not the film garners Oscar attention remains to be seen, but I sincerely hope O’Brien’s name comes up in that conversation. His dual performance is remarkable—easily one of the finest of his career, and one that proves he is not just good, but extraordinary.



