‘Him’ Review: Hail Mary’s Baby

Aaron Neuwirth reviews Him, an effective psychological sports thriller focused on how the system treats young, black athletes by way of bloody horror setpieces.

It’s somewhat surprising that there aren’t more body horror movies and psychological thrillers centered on sports. More specifically, the pressures that come from being tapped as a potential new face of an athletic franchise, and the grooming process that comes with it, seem ripe for satire. Certain haunting movies have explored the obsession individuals may have with achieving perfection (Whiplash, Black Swan, The Novice). Still, it’s a real thrill to see Him take on the world of professional football. Taken out of the Black List of scripts (a list of the best unproduced screenplays), producer Jordan Peele’s Monkeypaw Productions seems like a perfectly appropriate place for this story to wind up. It’s a social thriller, and angled to shed light on the way young, black athletes are treated by way of fever dream imagery, while we follow our lead character down the line of what appears to be a potential Faustian bargain. Whether or not the film fully succeeds, I found myself completely wrapped up in what was presented. I admired the filmmaking choices and have plenty of praise to offer for the efforts from star Marlon Wayans, who very much embodies what a “Him” could be.

Wayans stars as Isaiah White, a legendary quarterback for the San Antonio Saviors (this is the sort of film where neither the budget nor the content will lead to the NFL signing off on any participation, so one has to adjust to these nonexistent teams). Cameron “Cam” Cade (Tyriq Withers) is a young football player who has admired White all his life, partially due to his now-deceased father, who forced Cam to watch everything involving the star and pushed him to train to be the best. Cam’s real opportunity comes when he’s taken in by White to be mentored at his private compound out in the middle of nowhere. Of course, as already hinted at, the cost of chasing greatness may be too much for Cam to handle.

See Also: ‘One Battle After Another’ Review: A Mainstream Cinematic Revolution

him

I remember seeing director Justin Tipping’s first feature, Kicks, back in 2016. It was an urban coming-of-age story that employed fantastical realism as a means to convey itself more effectively. Him (originally titled GOAT) tilts the dial toward horror, and as a result, there’s a lot of effort put into things like sound design and quick edits to maximize the visceral feel of everything going down. Naturally, the collision of bodies in football allows these struggles to be dramatized and emphasized due to their violent outcomes. That said, Tipping goes a step further and adds a lot of colorful, heat-vision-based filters to really push the visuals to extreme limits when showing how monstrous the various players can be when unleashing the demons within. But do I mean that purely metaphorically?

From a plot standpoint, we’ve seen enough stories involving a gifted young person being tempted with unthinkable rewards if they travel down a difficult path that can be as violent as it is confusing. Better yet, we’ve watched these types of individuals get in over their heads because it all makes sense to them at the time. Whether that’s because of having paid their dues to get to a certain level, or because of encouragement by family, these are individuals who want to succeed based on what they feel has been earned. Naturally, that has to mean the other shoe will drop, and something sinister at play will be revealed.

him

Him has a lot of fun teasing out the nature of what exactly is going on. It’s not a film built around any particular twists, so it’s not as though this movie relies on the solving of a mystery. However, there’s a clear danger one can feel as soon as Cam enters White’s secluded local. Things ramp up from there, but you have to wonder if there’s just an overemphasis on what it is to go from college football to the big leagues, let alone under the wing of a GOAT-level quarterback. Is it Cam inflating what he’s feeling and the film lining up with that point of view, or are there more abstract notions taking place?

Withers is relatively new to the scene. He was one of the few decent elements in the dismal I Know What You Did Last Summer reboot. There’s also his killer role in one episode of the FX series Atlanta, where he leans into how he’s received as a biracial high school student (named Aaron, natch), and is tested for his “blackness” to potentially receive college tuition. One could argue how much Withers’ completion plays a role in this film, but it is interesting to watch him interact with this world. He’s clearly admired by those supporting him, but he walks a good line regarding how to play into the temptations that come with White’s world.

Obviously, it’s the young actor’s physicality that is put on display, with one of the best scenes of the film focused on how he’s poked, prodded, and measured as if he were lining up as cattle for the slaughter. Tying that into the way black athletes are treated is an interesting area for this film to explore. While it doesn’t do more than it must, it’s moments like this where Withers can accomplish a lot through expression.

him

Meanwhile, Marlon Wayans is on fire here. Whether or not one is a fan of his broader comedic work, I’ve always been happy to see what he’s capable of in films like Requiem for a Dream, Respect, or even his one scene in Air, where he completely shines. Just by the nature of him only having so many dramatic credits, this is career-best work from Wayans. He is devilishly funny, intense, physically intimidating, and fully able to lean into the surreal nature of what his character’s status requires of him. There’s no question that some form of evil is lurking within this man, but to what extent and where it takes him means Wayans must be present to have it pay off as strongly as it does, and he delivers.

It’s worth noting that the supporting cast is largely strong as well, while leaning largely into comedic territory. Jim Jefferies plays the in-house physician, administering all kinds of questionable treatments while bringing a sly sense of humor to his response to the craziness around him. Julia Fox is White’s wife and a social media influencer, which is precisely the role Fox knows how to nail. Lastly, Tim Heidecker is relishing his chance to play the sleazy sports agent, as if he’s channeling Jay Mohr from Jerry Maguire.

Given what he is up to, I expect reactions to come from what they are willing to accept by the time they reach the finale. I’ll say the movie chooses to go along with its metaphor in extreme ways, distancing itself from a plausible reality, and I was on board with it. At 96 minutes, with subject matter worth exploring but not entirely leaned into in a way that will open too many eyes, the fact that Him settles for an extremely bloody climax that’s not willing to provide concrete answers would only be a concern for me if it didn’t seem so clear in its intent. As it stands, I think Tipping was happy reveling in a sort of chaos that speaks to a lot of frustrating thoughts he must have about systems in place when it comes to athletes and what they are forced to be bound to.

So, I can understand potential divisions regarding responses to this film and where it goes, but I was still here to see what kind of journey Him wanted to take me on. Stylishly made, well-acted, and knowing how to keep itself moving and interesting, whether or not this is the definitive look at the types of people who suffer in relatable ways (thematically speaking), the film still functions as a creepy little thriller with the right kind of edge to help it stand out. I call that a touchdown.

Him opens in theaters and IMAX on September 19, 2025.

Written by
Aaron Neuwirth is a movie fanatic and Rotten Tomatometer-approved film critic from Orange County, California. He’s a member of the African American Film Critics Association, the Hollywood Critics Association, the Online Film Critics Society, and the Black Film Critics Circle. As an outgoing person who is always thrilled to discuss movies, he’s also a podcaster who has put far too many hours into published audio content associated with film and television. His work has been published at Variety, We Live Entertainment, Why So Blu, The Young Folks, Firstshowing.net, Screen Rant, and Hi-Def Ninja.

Your Vote

0 0

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.