Happy Hanukkah! Here comes another hodgepodge of holiday-season reviews. This set of write-ups includes a comedy-drama, a slice-of-life international film, a low-key heist film, a political thriller, a couple of documentaries, and an animated adventure. The following features reviews for Is This Thing On?, Left Handed Girl, The Mastermind, Anniversary, Zodiac Killer Project, The Perfect Neighbor, and The SpongeBob Movie: Search for SquarePants.
Is This Thing On?: 7 out of 10
The Setup: After many years together, Alex (Will Arnett) and Tess (Laura Dern) have reached an amicable end to their marriage, thus beginning the awkward stage of figuring out how to live separately while raising two boys and maintaining their friendships. Alex discovers a new hobby – stand-up comedy, and, in the process, learns more about himself and his relationship.
Review: While the material and choices made in A Star Is Born and Maestro may suggest more significant works from director Bradley Cooper when we look back years from now, there’s something about the smaller-scale nature of Is This Thing On? that says to me this is Cooper at his most confident as a filmmaker so far. While Matthew Libatique’s handheld, largely up-close cinematography is the closest this film comes to delivering a sense of deliberateness, this low-stakes comedy-drama has a sort of intimacy I appreciated. With no need to ramp up visual tricks or showcase performers in a way that highlights some physical superpower (as good as Lady Gaga was in her role), here’s a story that just wants to exist as a movie.
I will say it has a bit of an issue balancing its various plotlines. While the film essentially boils down to a midlife crisis movie, I did admire that it didn’t forget Dern’s character in the process. Rather than relegate her to just being “the ex-wife,” the film spends its second half making sure she has just as much agency. That said, there’s just not much that’s new in this storyline, let alone all that dramatic to suggest we need so much time taken away from the more interesting (and fun) side of this film, which is watching a terrific Arnett discover his gift for stand-up comedy.
With those scenes in mind, the film does get a lot of mileage out of Alex’s (perhaps too easy) climb as a decent comic. That said, the film settles into a laid-back vibe, allowing you to have fun watching his interactions in his world and following along with his messy friend group, which includes a solid Andra Day and Cooper as her husband, an actor nicknamed “Balls.” Showing that not every effort needs to take it all the way to the moon and back, Is This Thing On? is slight but affecting.
Where To Watch: Opening in select theaters on December 19, 2025, spreading wider on December 24.
Left-Handed Girl: 7 out of 10
The Setup: The story of a single mother and her two daughters who return to Taipei after several years of living in the countryside to open a stand at a buzzing night market. But when their traditional grandfather forbids his youngest left-handed granddaughter from using her “devil hand,” generations of family secrets begin to unravel.
Review: Having worked with filmmaker Sean Baker on most of his films, often serving as producer and co-writer, Shih-Ching Tsou is taking her own step up to bat with her first solo-directorial effort. Left-Handed Girl indeed recalls the grounded, gritty style of filmmaking Baker has deployed in several of his films, and it serves more as a slice-of-life drama than something more intense. In this case, we simply watch a family going through a transitional phase in their lives. How this registers with the audience may depend on the audience member, as while I normally find myself connecting to the hyper-specificity of these kinds of movies, all I could really do here was appreciate the effort.
Perhaps this has to do with the urgency of the story. Not that a major plotline is needed, but this is a film that primarily focuses on the characters’ emotions at a given moment, rather than on daily life in Taipei. And then the film eventually decides to have a plot to pay off. That’s not too dissimilar from something like The Florida Project, but I still feel as though a more accomplished film could have allowed its payoff to sink in deeper with me. As it stands, this is undoubtedly a well-assembled feature with solid work coming from the young/non-professional performers. And being left-handed myself, I hope this girl goes on to great things.
Where To Watch: Now available to stream on Netflix.
The Mastermind: 7 out of 10
The Setup: In 1970, J.B. Mooney (Josh O’Connor) and two cohorts wander into a museum in broad daylight and steal four paintings. When holding onto the art proves more difficult than stealing it, Mooney is forced to live on the run.
Review: Josh O’Connor is an arthouse movie star. While he’s had some mainstream hits with Challengers and Wake Up Dead Man (let’s assume it’s Netflix popularity counts), having built up esteem in recent years with films like La chimera, Rebuilding, and The History of Sound, this guy really seems to have it. I mean this in a good way, as I like watching O’Connor take on these various roles. Now seated with director Kelly Reichardt, he fits right into her brand of quiet, deliberately paced dramas that allow actors to really dig in internally and still shine on camera. As a heist film, this has a bit more momentum and action than one may be used to with one of her films, but it nevertheless contains all of what you’d expect from one of her projects, and O’Connor does well as the lead.
Filling out this ensemble cast, Alana Haim, Hope Davis, John Magaro, Gaby Hoffmann, and Bill Camp feel like a usual suspects-type list of supporting players I’d expect to see in a Reichardt film. That said, as one of her quirkier entries, they all mostly deliver as needed. Playing into reality to some degree (the robbery is actually inspired by a theft at the Worcester Art Museum) and providing this film further meaning by way of its time and place means being able to grab onto some extra layers of what to take away from all of this. That said, even if it were just a lark, the enjoyable performances and jazzy score by Rob Mazurek do plenty to satisfy the audience.
Where To Watch: Now available to stream on MUBI.
Anniversary: 5 out of 10
The Setup: A close-knit family is caught in the turmoil of a controversial rising movement known as “The Change.” Ellen and Paul (Diane Lane and Kyle Chandler) witness their lives fall apart when Ellen’s former student, Liz (Phoebe Dynevor), reappears and starts dating their son (Dylan O’Brien). As Liz becomes a part of the Taylor family, tensions rise, and loyalties are tested.
Review: There’s a solid idea at the core of this film, which relies on the varying political views of different family members who still meet up for yearly events to see each other. It’s a smart way to build out an ensemble cast without having to involve too many locations. Anniversary goes multiple steps further by turning a character drama into a dystopian political thriller, which is all well and good, except that for all the darkness and provocative ideas regarding authoritarianism, the film is still largely reliant on making things as bleak as possible in its attempt to make a point, rather than dig deeper. As a result, this is essentially an exploitation film more than anything.
We’ve seen other films like this, and some can handle this plotting better than others. Anniversary works best when the most committed actors nail what’s given to them in an otherwise uneven script. Chandler, Dynevor, O’Brien, and Madeline Brewer fare best in this regard. Every character is eventually given something crucial to work with, but where the film is otherwise overly melodramatic, the actors who shine best really nail the tone.
Given where we are in reality when it comes to American politics, one has to wonder if director Jan Komasa and writer Lori Rosene-Gambino are doing enough to make their points rather than point a finger in a direction and attempt to generalize the idea of what would be an unfortunate way to see things get taken over by “a” side as opposed to something more specific. Granted, films like this aim to seem like they can apply to anyone by not being too explicit, but it also starts to feel like a too-easy excuse to go harder and deliver a sharper feature.
Where To Watch: Now available on digital and VOD.
Zodiac Killer Project: 7 out of 10
The Setup: A film about a film that was never made, this boldly original essay begins as an exploration of one man’s obsession with catching the Zodiac Killer but quickly unfolds into an anti-true-crime investigation into our cultural obsession with the genre. Against the backdrop of sun-drenched landscapes, deserted hallways, and empty homes, Charlie Shackleton guides us through the film his team would have made, projecting a speculative narrative into our imaginations with irreverent humor and razor-sharp precision. Zodiac
Review: It’s probably important to understand what one is getting into before they sign on for this film, but I was a big fan of what Zodiac Killer Project is actually going after. Without outright saying it, this is almost a parody film. While serious matters are being addressed, and the situation that brought this out for filmmaker Charlie Shackleton is real, it’s the choices he made with what he had that allow this doc to reach a whole other level.
Rather than find a way to detail why this attempt at a documentary didn’t come together, Shackleton essentially assembles a candid take on what it would have been like to make this documentary, with running narration going over what camera choices he’d make, the editing that would be showcased, and other elements that dig into the cliched nature of how similar murder-related projects play out in an attempt to keep the viewer captivated by what they are seeing.
It’s entertaining to someone like me, who isn’t very involved in that sort of media, and I can only imagine that those truly tuned into this genre will find something relatable in what this movie is doing. That being said, the best parts of this doc find Shackleton failing to contain himself when it comes to seeing the humor in what he’s doing, let alone nailing down the exact methodology that comes with these sorts of form of entertainment that also double back to deal with his subject to some degree properly. As a sort of meta-commentary complete with additional tangents and a sense of humor, this is the sort of strange experiment that worked out quite well.
Where To Watch: Now playing in select theaters.
The Perfect Neighbor: 8 out of 10
The Setup: A seemingly minor neighborhood dispute in Florida escalates into deadly violence. Police bodycam footage and investigative interviews expose the consequences of Florida’s “stand your ground” laws.
Review: While the circumstances surrounding this documentary are tragic, I can admire the skills of director Geeta Gandbhir and her team in finding an effective way to address this subject. Relying almost entirely on police bodycam footage, while all documentaries have an angle to get across a particular point, there’s an element of remove with this approach, and a lack of further explanation to push the viewer in a certain direction when it comes to taking everything presented at face value. Clearly, biases and racism come into play as to why things escalate in certain ways, depending on who is involved in the scenario presented, and all we need to see is the footage plainly put on display.
Of course, this isn’t just a matter of watching a “Karen” go way too far. It’s an examination of the area, the diverse population, and the steps taken by the police, which could be further argued in terms of how responsive they chose to be, given the number of grievances leading up to heartbreaking results. I don’t know how various permissions are obtained when assembling a documentary like this, but it is no doubt effective to have this sort of information and detail available, and to understand how proper filmmaking can genuinely make an impact on perception. Fascinating and devastating in equal measures, not a great neighbor, but an excellent documentary.
Where To Watch: Now available to stream on Netflix.
The SpongeBob Movie: Search for SquarePants: 6 out of 10
The Setup: Desperate to be a big guy, SpongeBob (Tom Kenny) sets out to prove his bravery to Mr. Krabs (Clancy Brown) by following The Flying Dutchman (Mark Hamill) – a mysterious swashbuckling ghost pirate – on a seafaring comedy-adventure that takes him to the deepest depths of the deep sea, where no Sponge has gone before.
Review: Because why not end things on a high note? Here’s a take on the new SpongeBob movie – it’s fun. No, I don’t think this effort comes close to the best of SpongeBob, as all the films seem to be still chasing after the enormous fun found in 2004’s original SpongeBob SquarePants Movie, let alone the surprisingly delightful cinematic follow-up 11 years later, Sponge Out of Water. Still, there’s an oddball innocence that hasn’t been lost with this wacky animated creation, which brings me joy.
The plot is fine, serving as an excuse to put SpongeBob and his best friend Patrick (Bill Fagerbakke) in increasingly silly situations. And I always enjoy some of the left-field vocal choices and the veteran actors cast in these movies. Still, nothing has come close to the utter glee seen from David Hasselhoff or Antonio Banderas in previous adventures. That said, Hamill is always down to put on a voice and create a character, which delivers here. The positive messaging is reasonably simple as well, but at least we get a fun song out of it, as Ice Spice’s “Big Guy” delivers a better bop than whatever it was that Smurfs tried to deliver earlier this year. So yes, this SpongeBob is a decently fun big guy, and that’s okay.
Where To Watch: Opening in theaters on December 19, 2025.







