‘Nosferatu’ Review: A Modernist Symphony of Bloody Horror

Aaron Neuwirth reviews Nosferatu, director/writer Robert Eggers' update on the classic gothic horror film, featuring his own superb and dark sensabilities.
User Rating: 8

To say we’ve had our share of cinematic Dracula stories over the years would be an understatement, and they’ve varied in quality. Nosferatu, the unauthorized and unofficial adaptation of Bram Stoker’s novel, on the other hand, has faired quite well. F. W. Murnau’s 1922 silent film is a German Expressionist classic, and Werner Herzog’s 1979 take is one of the best remakes one could ask for. Sure, we can skip past Vampire in Venice and Transylvania Twist, but 2000’s darkly comedic Shadow of the Vampire, chronicling a fictionalized version of the making of the original, is another delight. So, as far as I was concerned, director and all-around moody weirdo Robert Eggers seemed equipped to produce a new version of the film that inspired him to become a filmmaker and arrive with good odds of delivering a successful retelling. Having seen it, I can easily say I succumbed to this film’s darkness.

The story is largely the same as it ever was. When you think of aged vampires living in isolated castles, you will obviously find yourself concerned with real estate deals, which is where this story’s focus starts. Nicholas Hoult is Thomas Hutter, a young businessman tasked to meet with the reclusive Count Orlok (Bill Skarsgård) at his castle in the Carpathian Mountains in Transylvania to secure a housing deal near Hutter’s own residence. Of course, this is merely a ruse. Orlok has other plans, including his obsession with Thomas’ wife, Ellen (Lily-Rose Depp), and wreaking havoc by bringing the plague everywhere he goes.

See Also: ‘Beetlejuice Beetlejuice’ Review: More Ghosts, Less The Most

Nosferatu

While there are some alterations, new characters, and other unique elements, this is essentially the same Nosferatu/Dracula story we’ve seen before. That’s not an inherent detriment, just a point of observation. Eggers has his monster, a couple of respectable men in over their heads, a weak-minded man forced to serve his master, an off-kilter professor with designs to slay the demon, and the one woman who may be the ultimate solution. As one could surmise, the importance and value of this version of Nosferatu comes down to how Eggers deploys his own directorial style, using all these pieces in a way he sees fit for more than just an exercise in gothic horror filmmaking.

Looking at Eggers’ three previous films, The Witch, The Lighthouse, and The Northman, it’s not hard to understand how Nosferatu fits in. Using the period setting, we are once again treated to a feature steeped in atmosphere and rooted in historical authenticity regarding various design and character choices. And yet, we also find ourselves following characters grappling with folklore concerning vampires and what to do about the supernatural elements that they find unbelievable yet the only true answer to what they are dealing with.

Eggers pulls out the stops to make this register as needed without breaking the bank. Nosferatu doesn’t necessarily require the biggest budget to pull off what’s needed here. Instead, Eggers focuses more on the vintage cameras he can use, the sets that can be built, and the locations he can find (the film was mostly shot in Prague) to deliver an experience entrenched in old-school sensibilities yet equipped with enough of a modernist touch to reflect what can be accomplished today. For example, this is a color film, but it’s often presented as if life is drained out of what we see, leading to a cooler color palette only offset by the occasional warm glow of candlelight.

Nosferatu

Atmosphere, in a general sense, is a true highlight of this feature. It’s not just the use of shadow and the brooding score by Robin Carolan. When we first see Thomas getting closer to Orlok’s castle, we watch him grip his heart as if a dark cloud of evil is invading his body. Late-night visits from the vampire’s spirit may bring a certain glow to the doorways of his potential victims, yet it’s easy to recognize the threat. So much of this film is devoted to the foreboding nature of Nosferatu’s presence, only to be followed up by bloody instances of violence and other forms of horrific imagery to establish just how gross this all can be.

I could say there’s beauty in the gruesome nature of what’s taking place. Still, it’s better to compliment the subtle visual effects at play, let alone the casting, makeup, and costuming used to bring these characters to life. Skarsgård is tremendous as Count Orlok. Wisely hidden from all the marketing (you won’t see any pictures of him here), the choices made to depict this version of Nosferatu as a monstrous Transylvanian nobleman are quite excellent, different from what we’ve seen before, and, true to Eggers’ form, accurate to the time and even Stoker’s original novel.

Additionally, at least one other actor rises to the occasion of being as disgusting as possible, but I won’t say which. Instead, looking at the male side of things, Hoult delivers the goodness I expect from his role as the innocent Thomas Hutter, who is naïve in nature and can hardly believe the level of evil that exists in the world. Aaron Taylor-Johnson plays Friedrich Harding, a friend to Thomas and a more pompous man less willing to believe in a blood-sucking demon until it is too late. If anything, I could have seen these actors switch parts and perhaps allow Taylor-Johnson to be more successful in what’s required of him (Hoult already knows how to charm while playing up proud arrogance), but it’s of little matter.

Nosferatu

Willem Dafoe is More enjoyable by default, as not Dr. Abraham Van Helsing but Prof. Albin Eberhart Von Franz. The film is having the most fun when he is around, bringing his esteem and a certain level of detachment to his conversations, reminding the audience that this is a movie about a vampire’s dastardly real estate deal. Dafoe’s ease at grounding exaggerated qualities down to a human level is welcome, with additional fun coming from his familiarity with the creature in question on a meta-level already.

Most surprising, however, is Depp’s portrayal of Ellen. Eggers wisely adjusts the story to be more focused around her role in all of this, adding new layers to what she means to Nosferatu and just how bonded she is to the darkness that enraptures everything connected to them. To match these requirements, Depp uses her slight frame and seeming innocence to bring the audience close before revealing the tortured soul and what these afflictions have done to Ellen. Beyond just her interactions with the other characters, there’s a formidable physical performance at play to heighten the impact Depp’s supposed to have on all involved, allowing her to stand next to Skarsgård as the film’s MVP.

Nosferatu

As far as other filmmaking choices are concerned, at 132 minutes, this is the longest Nosferatu yet but certainly packed with effort to bring this time period and its mythological elements to life. Given how familiar I am with this story, watching how this version unfolds is never uninteresting. Still, it does take its time in certain areas, as opposed to Coppola’s Dracula, for a relatable example, which bludgeoned the audience with its style as often as possible. That said, Eggers isn’t dancing around how much of a horror film Nosferatu should be. This film features plenty of blood and gore, many rats to feel sickened by, and other elongated sections designed to unnerve the audience. The music and Jarin Blaschke’s cinematography follow suit by emphasizing the terror at play when needed.

While I can’t think of every effort at this offhand, the notion of a filmmaker looking back to the roots of what made them want to pursue their passion and deliver their own version of that cinematic vision is intriguing. Yes, it can be labeled in certain ways pertaining to ego, but at the same time, it must also be daunting to say, “I want to remake a classic film that inspired me to direct.” As it stands, Nosferatu is a superb accomplishment that speaks to many of the core elements that have made Robert Eggers such an exciting filmmaker to have emerged in this modern era of horror, let alone cinema in general. For a film currently scheduled to be released alongside more family-friendly offerings this holiday season, know that Eggers’ darkness can loom over theaters and haunt all who choose it in a manner that’s plenty nourishing.

Nosferatu opens in theaters on December 25, 2024.

Nosferatu

8
Great
Written by
Aaron Neuwirth is a movie fanatic and Rotten Tomatometer-approved film critic from Orange County, California. He’s a member of the African American Film Critics Association, the Hollywood Critics Association, the Online Film Critics Society, and the Black Film Critics Circle. As an outgoing person who is always thrilled to discuss movies, he’s also a podcaster who has put far too many hours into published audio content associated with film and television. His work has been published at Variety, We Live Entertainment, Why So Blu, The Young Folks, Firstshowing.net, Screen Rant, and Hi-Def Ninja.

Your Vote

0 0

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.