Review: The Walking Dead 10x04, “Silence The Whisperers”

Aaron Neuwirth reviews The Walking Dead Season 10, Episode 4, "Silence the Whisperers" in which folks don't take too kindly to Lydia and Negan around town.

Despite earning a mention in the title, we actually take a break from the Whisperers on this week’s The Walking Dead to deal with paranoia concerning them. “Silence the Whisperers” is a bit all over in terms of tone, but it does give us a chance to take a look at how the various communities are handling the presence of the Whisperers as a continually threat lurking in the background, and using a couple of scapegoats as a way to vent that frustration. This episode also continues to show what progress the series has made in letting the larger ensemble have a chance to speak up.

Interestingly, everything begins on a relatively innocent note. Of course, this means things will go bad any second, but the opening minutes find Daryl joining a group for a friendly dinner. Carol seems to be coping with last week’s events but is working on it. Magna and Yumiko are having their time together. All of this comes to an end thanks to a fallen tree on a wall at the Hilltop. Was it an attack by the Whisperers? Was it random? It all fuels speculation.

I’m of the mind that a tree falling in the woods and everyone around to see it is likely a situation of chance. Alpha and her crew have better ways to go after our heroes if she wanted to, which we’ve already seen in the past. Regardless, this episode does once again find our survivors fighting hours on end against waves of walkers. We get more chances to see the newer cast members in action, with a reminder of the effective use of slingshots to go along with bow and arrows, and whatever heavy tool now-skinny Dan Fogler is using to help hold them back.

This is a subplot of the episode, though it does feel important enough, as a tree falling on the Hilltop is seeing the barrier of safety get shattered for our heroes as a whole. It means fighting off the outside, but it also means working together to solve the problem. There are other problems to worry about, but seeing Michonne, Eugene, and others figure out the best solution is a fine way of letting us know how close-knit everyone is at this point. There’s less focus on who shouldn’t be involved and more respect given to those who are the right people needed in a time of crisis.

Sadly, this isn’t quite the case for Alexandria. With the looming threat of the Whisperers, there are some rotten eggs that are not taking well to Alpha’s daughter, Lydia, walking around town. It’s an understandable sense of resentment, but things are, of course, taken too far. Props to Lydia for fighting back by just acting weird and cutting open an animal on a table in front of her bullies. It doesn’t end well though.

Being ambushed in the dark, in a 3 on 1 fight, is no way to handle anything, and it’s bad luck for the bad apples that Negan has been looking out for Lydia. In his attempts to defend the helpless kid, Negan accidentally kills the one woman who still wants revenge for the death of the Highwaymen (a group I still wish lasted longer). That action puts everyone against Negan, once again, making it time for a discussion amongst the council to figure out what makes sense.

There’s a lot to look at here. Most interesting is how much I suddenly care for Negan in this situation. I’ve not been shy about showing my disdain for his portrayal in this series, with only moments registering as the right blend of his schtick with an actual character. It’s not a fault of Jeffrey Dean Morgan, I’ve just always been apprehensive toward the abrasiveness of his character and his band of violent idiots. Putting Negan in jail hasn’t helped much, but finally letting him free enough to discuss things with others and have more than sage asshole wisdom has given him better layers to play on.

It especially works when putting him with Lydia, who he can easily relate to. Daryl is another character that pushes him the right way. Despite feeding the man dog food, there hasn’t been a lot of interactions between these two characters (likely because having Daryl with Negan too long would make the audience wonder why Daryl wouldn’t just kill Negan faster than he killed a tank all those years ago). Now, however, with Daryl promoted to de-facto lead of the series, he gets a chance to show how conflicted he is about decisions to make in his regard. It’s good stuff to consider.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t ultimately matter, as Negan escapes his prison by the end of this episode, which can go several ways, as far as everyone else is concerned. I have my own theories, which any comic fan could probably think of as well, but we’ll see what happens. As it stands, Gabriel’s choice to sleep on things has only complicated matters.

Amid all this plot-heavy stuff, there is also the other thing – Michonne and Ezekiel. Dealing with the loss of his Kingdom, Carol, and just a sense of control in general, the man is at his lowest. It’s sad to see; however, Michonne’s encounter and the possible saving move was perhaps for the benefit of both. The episode takes a breather and lets these two talk about things. It’s a nice sequence that follows up the surprise kiss they share (though Ezekiel says he wasn’t at his best in that department). Perhaps this will be explored further, but taking the regal nature of Ezekiel away has taken away some of the fun for the character. Understandably, everyone needs an arc, so let’s hope things can now be on the rise for the guy.

By the end of this episode, things seem to be back in a better place for many. Negan is still on the loose, but Michonne, Judith, Luke, among others, are all off to Oceanside, while Eugene is staying in Hilltop to help fix the wall. It’s all a bit too pat, honestly, given all the hugs and best wishes going along with the state of things concerning outside threats (not to mention the overly emotional pop song). Of course, that only means the silence of Whisperers this week won’t last that long.

Dead Bits:

  • Zombie Kill of the Week: Judith actually earns the honor this week, having Michonne’s back and putting her sword skills to use.
  • This week’s episode was directed by former Walking Dead cast member, Michael Cudlitz. I don’t always call out the flashy elements, but he did find with a couple long takes during the walker action sequences, and in handling Siddiq’s PTSD freak out and ice bowl plunge. At the same time, he made a lot of weird choices that hurt understanding the geography of a few scenes.
  • Dark Aaron continues to be of little help this week.
  • Michonne and Judith talking about bullies had a lot of nice touches.
  • Daryl getting all made at Negan was a delight to see, as rage Daryl tends to be a good watch.
  • “I lost my Kingdom.” – Ezekiel is a fascinating persona, given how far he’s come and what he no longer has control over. As much as I like his optimism, I hope the show duly delves into his state of mind and how to rise above it.
  • The thought that Lydia is the key to keeping the communities safe makes plenty of sense. Let’s see how far that gets everyone.
  • Thanks for reading and feel free to hear what me and a few other fans of the show have to say about the series on The Walking Dead TV Podcast.

Written by
Aaron Neuwirth is a movie fanatic and Rotten Tomatometer-approved film critic from Orange County, California. He’s a member of the African American Film Critics Association, the Hollywood Critics Association, the Online Film Critics Society, and the Black Film Critics Circle. As an outgoing person who is always thrilled to discuss movies, he’s also a podcaster who has put far too many hours into published audio content associated with film and television. His work has been published at Variety, We Live Entertainment, Why So Blu, The Young Folks,, Screen Rant, and Hi-Def Ninja.

Your Rating

7 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.